*Smucker’s makes a good pineapple jam. Locals who shop at Lancaster Central Market can also purchase it from the stand with a large assortment of homemade jams across from The Goodie Shoppe.
Tip: If the onions begin to brown too quickly, you may reduce the heat slightly. The key is for them to become lightly golden over time as the moisture very slowly cooks off. You do want to stir occasionally but allowing the onions to sit untouched for stretches facilitates the caramelization process. The longer the onions cook, the sweeter they become.