Vanilla extract is easy to make at home with just two ingredients. The following how-to offers helpful details on which beans and liquor to use and how to store for practical use and gifting.
Every year, I tell myself that I’m going to do my Christmas shopping early—and wrap the gifts too. In September, this seems like such a reasonable goal. Then, Thanksgiving comes and goes and I have yet to set foot in a store or order a single item online.
Ninety-nine percent of my issue is coming up with clever ideas. Knowing that I can’t possibly be the only one with this problem, I have developed an assortment of do-it-yourself gifts that are uncomplicated, economical, and practical.
During this busy time of year, the small effort behind a gift that can readily be put to use is always much appreciated and creates value beyond what is measured in dollars and cents.
Homemade vanilla extract requires just two ingredients — vanilla beans and alcohol — and makes a practical holiday or hostess gift. For a bigger bang, pair it with a recipe for your favorite cookies or quick bread calling for vanilla. Include the actual baked good if you’re feeling especially industrious!
Good extract takes baked goods to another level and the sweet aroma is hard to resist. And seeing those little black flecks in your dessert signals quality and something a little special. There really is no substitute for vanilla.
Types of vanilla beans:
When I first contemplated this DIY project, I hesitated at the high cost of fancy vanilla beans. After doing a little research, however, I learned that cheaper, grade B vanilla beans–the ones that look shriveled and dry–are perfectly fine for making extract. Their aroma may be slightly less pronounced than that of grade A beans, but their lower moisture content means a less diluted final product.
Madagascar vanilla beans are ideal for a traditional extract. Doing it yourself, however, creates options. Tahitian beans offer undertones of chocolate and cherry, while Mexican beans are smooth and smoky. For a bolder flavor, Ugandan beans could be used.
Many sources exist for buying vanilla beans in bulk at a cost that makes for reasonably priced gifts. I have purchased online through Beanilla, and locally at Lancaster Central Market’s The Herb Shop.
Best liquor to use:
Top shelf liquor isn’t necessary either, but choose something that you’d like to drink. Though many vanilla extract recipes call for vodka–which is certainly acceptable–I think bourbon offers a more complex flavor. Rum and brandy are good options too.
How to store the vanilla:
Pretty jars can be found at craft stores or online. Just make sure there is a tight-fitting lid. You can even remove labels from and thoroughly wash empty condiment jars.
Helpful sticky label removing hint: For stubborn labels, peel off as much of the paper label as possible, then spread a layer of peanut butter over the sticky adhesive. After sitting for 30 minutes or so, the oil in the peanut butter will dissolve the adhesive, and the goop should rub right off!
PRICING DETAILS: As a comparison, a four-ounce bottle of name brand (Nielsen-Massey) pure Madagascar vanilla extract retails for $10.95. Eight ounces of the same vanilla costs $19.95. Recently, I purchased a package of 25 Madagascar vanilla beans from Beanilla.com for $16.99 and free shipping. Twenty-five beans will allow for 40 ounces of vanilla extract or 10 four-ounce bottles. I used an old bottle of bourbon that we had on hand.
- 5 vanilla beans (I prefer Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Beans; see sourcing information, below)
- 1 cup (8 ounces) bourbon, vodka, rum or brandy
- 1 (12-ounce or bigger) bottle or jar for soaking
- Glass bottles for packaging (3 1/2- to 4-ounce bottles are a nice size for gift giving)
Slice halfway through the long side of the beans. (You want a slit all the way down one side of the bean without cutting the bean in half.)
Place the beans in a jar or bottle.
Pour in the alcohol, making sure the beans are covered.
If your jar is not tall and narrow enough for the whole beans to be fully submerged in the alcohol, you may cut the beans in half or quarters.
Place the lid tightly on the jar and shake well.
Store the jar in a cool, dark place and shake once or twice a week.
The flavor will be fully developed in about 8 weeks, although you may begin using the extract after a month.
The beans may be removed after the waiting period, but this is not essential. If left in, the flavor of the extract will continue to develop.
If you wish to give the extract as a gift before the waiting period is over, simply make it in the gift jars, noting on the tag that the vanilla will be ready and completely delicious on or after such-and-such date.
- If the beans are left in the jar, you may top off the bottle with additional alcohol as you use the extract. Eventually all the flavor will be extracted from the original vanilla beans, so you’ll want to periodically replace the old beans with fresh ones.
- The little flecks of seeds are a nice touch, but the extract may be strained through a coffee filter if a clear extract is preferred.
- When the vanilla beans are removed, they may be dried out and placed in a sugar canister to lightly flavor the sugar.
What a great idea! In the last couple of years, I learned how to make Limoncello, and now I make my own.
Now it’s your recipe for vanilla, which I love, coupled with a better understanding of how liqueurs are made, the sky’s the limit. I will definitely be using your recipe and advice. THANK YOU
You’re welcome, Michael! Homemade Limoncello is such a treat, and the homemade vanilla will be equally special for its own uses – and there are so many!
thank you so much. I am definitely going to make some vanilla. The cost of pure vanilla here is unaffordable for me.
I just made your soup mix know off and I love it. Having that as a dip with crunchy zucchini oven fries.
Thanks for so generously sharing your great recipes.
Hi Jenny, The cost of vanilla has skyrocketed recently. I hope this provides a good alternative for you. As for the soup, so happy you made and enjoyed!
Just was on the Beanilla site and the price for 10 grade B beans is $55.45. Am I missing something in the way they are being sold or has the price just skyrocketed. Thanks.
Wow! It’s been some time since I posted this, and I haven’t purchased vanilla beans in a while as I’ve been working through all my homemade extract. As you can see by the pricing I mentioned at the time, it was much lower. Given the increase, I’d look at places like Walmart. The quality might be a little lower–meaning a dryer bean–but I think the end result once soaked will still be quite good.