Prep-Ahead Open-Faced Egg Sandwiches (gluten-free option)

Jump to recipe

My most vivid Easter memories include the year my dog, Ruffy, ate the contents of my Easter basket while we were at church.  I also had a general fear of the Easter Bunny and serious concern that my older sister would find more than her fair share of eggs.

We spent hours decorating those eggs.  My mom boiled a dozen for each of us and equipped us with the supplies necessary to create colorful, patterned eggs that we always considered too pretty to eat.

As a mom, I now boil a dozen eggs for each of my kids, and they kindly share a couple so that I may relive those fun childhood memories.  These masterpieces are not just for hiding and seeking, however.  We do eat them, and I have devised a few favorite ways to take them a step or two past our favorite egg salad.

The prep-ahead aspect makes these sandwiches an easy breakfast.  We also enjoy them as a welcome breakfast-for-dinner option, paired with a salad or green vegetable. Fresh fruit or sliced, vine-ripened tomatoes are an equally delightful pairing when in season.

When tomatoes are at their best, try topping a small tomato half or thick tomato slice with some of the egg mixture and broiling until golden brown.

Prep-Ahead Open-Faced Egg Sandwiches
While regular English muffins work well in this recipe, I enjoy the heartier Ezekiel muffins. For a gluten-free version, Amaranth’s Gluten Free Sesame Sandwich Rolls are fantastic, depending on where you live. (Look for both in the organic freezer section.) Toast them until they are crisp to create the perfect, crunchy base for the creamy, cheesy egg topping.
  • 7 large or 6 extra large eggs, hard-boiled, peeled and chopped
  • 1 cup grated cheddar cheese
  • 1/4 cup plain 2% Greek yogurt
 (I have more recently used non-fat Greek yogurt with good results)
  • 1/4 cup mayonnaise
  • 6 slices bacon, cooked and chopped
  • 1/2 tablespoon Dijon mustard
  • 1 dash Worcestershire sauce
  • Kosher salt and freshly ground pepper to taste
  • 4 whole English or Ezekiel muffins, split and toasted until crunchy
  1. Combine all ingredients except muffins. Cover and store in fridge until ready to use–overnight is fine if having for breakfast.
  2. Spread the egg mixture on the toasted muffin halves. In an oven preheated to 400 degrees F, bake for three minutes, and then broil for one minute or until bubbly and golden brown on top. (Watch closely while broiling.) Leftovers, if there are any, reheat well in the oven or toaster oven. Recipe doubles easily.
  3. Option: Reserve roughly 1/3 cup of the cheese and a couple tablespoons of the chopped bacon to sprinkle over the top of the egg mixture before baking the muffins. Also, to easily and evenly toast several English muffins at once, place them on a baking sheet and bake at 350 degrees until crisp.
The Fountain Avenue Kitchen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Laura Perry

    Hi Ann,

    We love breakfast for dinner at my house.
    This one looks like a winner! By the way,
    loved the photos of your kitchen that you
    posted last week!

  2. Cris

    Hi Ann, it looks delicious. But I wonder what happens when you heat mayonaise. Doens’t it ‘split’ and I don’t know if this is the right word (native tongue is Dutch).

    1. Ann

      I have used mayonnaise in several recipes which are baked and actually really like the way it turns out. I think the texture actually improves and the mayo browns slightly. In the States, people often use mayonnaise in dips that are baked. If you try, I hope you like! Thanks so much for the comment, Cris!

  3. Viki Yaeger

    Hi Ann- these look excellent. We try to alternate breakfast foods to break the tedium, but I like to prep ahead a huge batch and freeze, which I have done successfully with muffin tin versions of an egg/cheese strata like dish. Wondering if you can freeze these using baggies, and if so- how to ensure the defrosting/warming up doesn’t make them soggy? Or would this not lend well to freezing?

    1. Ann

      Hi Viki,
      I have not frozen these but, coincidently, a good friend just told me she did and it worked very well. I would recommend freezing, unwrapped, on a baking sheet. Once frozen, transfer to an airtight container or bag. That way, they won’t stick together or to the top of the bag.

  4. Pingback: Keep Your Cool, Here’s 20 Ways to Use All Those Easter Eggs!

  5. Pingback: The Fountain Avenue Kitchen – Super Easy Egg & Avocado Salad